• hollerpixie@lemm.ee
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    10 hours ago

    Ah, I get what you mean now by inflammatory statements (after a thorough reread) and why there may have been downvotes from that. Though interestingly, I didn’t feel my comment was very inflammatory and it got downvoted too. 😅

    I was looking at it more from just a standpoint of systemd itself, and honestly, just looking at it from the standpoint that fedora and rhel can tend to be industry leaders for change. Honestly, if RHEL and Ubuntu together made some sort of meaningful change from a system perspective, I think we would see that move downstream.

    As far as my use of the term bloated, I’m looking at it strictly from a standpoint for the amount of code that goes into the system. The more code you have, the more entries for security risks. I’m not saying that there’s anything that’s particularly better out there right now, but I think we should always be looking for alternatives regardless of what your views are for the people that created the code. KISS philosophy, basically. That and being open to change to avoid stagnation.

    • jamesbunagna@discuss.online
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      8 hours ago

      Ah, I get what you mean now by inflammatory statements

      Actually, it wasn’t me that said that 😅. I do find it in jrgd’s reply, though.

      Though interestingly, I didn’t feel my comment was very inflammatory and it got downvoted too. 😅

      For the record, I also didn’t downvote your comment 😜. Though, looking at how well-received my previous reply has been, I can’t ignore the possibility that peeps that agreed with what I said also chose to downvote your comment.

      I was looking at it more from just a standpoint of systemd itself

      Sorry, I don’t think I completely understood you here.

      just looking at it from the standpoint that fedora and rhel can tend to be industry leaders for change.

      I absolutely agree with you that Fedora and Red Hat are very effective agents of change. So yes, if they would get behind an alternative for systemd, then that would definitely get traction.

      if RHEL and Ubuntu together made

      Has something like this ever happened in the past? I can’t recollect a collaboration of sorts between these two entities. If anything, they seem to be at odds with eachother: Mir vs Wayland, Snap vs Flatpak and even Upstart vs systemd. Though, at least so far, Red Hat holds an impressive winning track record.

      I think we would see that move downstream.

      Absolutely. But, and this is my inner-systemd-skeptic talking, systemd is ridiculously intertwined with the current Linux landscape and often times new updates even show a glimpse of how much more intermingling we’ll get in the future. I hope we’ll eventually get something to systemd like what PipeWire has been to PulseAudio. That’s why development into alternatives like dinit and s6 is of utmost importance.

      As far as my use of the term bloated, I’m looking at it strictly from a standpoint for the amount of code that goes into the system.

      Suckless it is 😜. It’s a fine definition. Thank you for that. But, I got to ask, where is the line drawn? Like, the Linux kernel, by virtue of being monolithic, has to be bloated as well. Right? So, if that’s the case, is somehow the kernel’s bloat okay while bloat is unaccepted for the system and service manager? If so, why? I’m genuinely curious.

      The more code you have, the more entries for security risks.

      Sure~ish. Deep discussion. I’m fine with giving this to ya.

      I’m not saying that there’s anything that’s particularly better out there right now

      I suppose some peeps will enjoy themselves with what’s out there. Do you happen to use an alternative on a daily-basis?

      but I think we should always be looking for alternatives regardless of what your views are for the people that created the code. KISS philosophy, basically. That and being open to change to avoid stagnation.

      Wholeheartedly agree 😊.